No pain No Gain
Posted June 19th, 2008 by Erin KaeseI think there is truth to this saying.
Of course, how one defines “pain” is the determining factor. In terms of exercise, I think the “pain” is a good thing. It’s the burn, struggle, high, and/or sweat equity of the workout. It’s what you come for.
If it doesn’t hurt a little, what’s the point? You suffer a little (or even a lot) and feel awesome afterward. And it doesn’t matter too much what you do, swim, bike, run, yoga, weight lifting, aerobics…
Bikram Yoga is my workout of choice and it perfectly illustrates my point.
Our studio in Old Town is “known” for its heat. I can attest to its heat factor from my experiences at other studios across the country and from the comments I’ve heard from others. And this studio does GREAT business, despite the fact that its students often whine “it’s too hot.” I usually complain when it’s not hot enough!
But, these same students come back. And soon they too complain if the heat isn’t up to par.
Why? Because the heat takes this yoga practice to a new level. With no heat, there is little struggle. It’s too easy. (Keep in mind that Bikram is for beginners.) And while we all like easy (or think we do), most of us won’t pay for it.
My brother recently began practicing Bikram yoga in Bend, Oregon, and he still says he hates it. But, he goes back 3+ times a week. In fact, he just completed 21 days in a row! He goes back because it’s hard; it works; and he sees results. (Read his story here.) And it’s the combination of the 26 poses over 90 minutes with heat that produces results.
The Bend studio is a good one. The heat is decent and the instruction is top-notch. I can’t say the same for some of the other studios I have practiced in. I’ve been in classes where at the slightest sign of any student becoming fatigued, the teacher opens a window or door or turns the heat down. I’ve even heard where one teacher said “we don’t want to risk anything.” Risk what? I’m still shaking my head at this nonsense. No pain, No gain. Try it.
I would wager that these same studios are not doing as well as they could financially. If I want to be coddled and have a nice glisten, I sure as heck don’t need to pony up $10-$15/class. I can perform some nice and easy stretches on my own for free. Okay, I admit, the Bikram sequence is quite genius, but for loyalists, it is ALSO the heat that keeps us coming back for more.
The Old Town San Diego studio is huge by comparison to others and the class numbers have increased significantly over the last year. Sure yoga is becoming more and more mainstream, but I have another explanation for the surge. I call it the Starbucks Effect.
Other burgeoning studios (such at CorePower) offer “hot yoga” or a Bikram knock-off as one of many class options. Undoubtedly there is a population that discovers hot yoga this way and then realizes that the genuine article can be had elsewhere, e.g., at a Bikram studio where there is more pain and gain.
Sbux popularized coffee drinking and MANY independent coffee houses benefitted from the free advertising. And while Bikram Choudhury (the inventor of Bikram Yoga), is certainly right to be disgruntled over his namesake being used without permission, I think it has helped some studios such as mine.
So, why do you exercise? And what is exercise really? Hmmm. If you want to stay active and fit wherever you go, check us out!
June 20th, 2008 at 6:42 am
amen, sister!
i invest a lot of money into my yoga practice because i know how much i benefit from a consistent practice. with that money i expect heat, humidity and a teacher that has a vested interest in his/her students. i recently moved from the west to the east coast…i am continually astounded by teachers who apparently believe they are helping their students by making sure the room is not “too” hot, by offering them drinks in the middle of class and even pouring cold water on their ankles. WHAT? these actions, in my opinion, are not in the service of the students and will only foster bad habits. has anyone ever died in a bikram yoga class? okay then, turn up the heat and start teaching some discipline…the students will love you for it!
June 20th, 2008 at 2:33 pm
“We’re not selling blueberry cheesecake!” and “Bikram’s torture chamber”
These are two common refrains from any bikram class, but erin is right, MANY studios just get lazy with the heat. I think it starts with the owners. The owners need to commit to a certain discipline. I’ve practiced in Old Town before and Jim and Emma run what is arguably the tightest ship in the bikram franchise.
Unfortunately the same can not be said for many other studios. Also, some studios just don’t have the right technology for the heat — can’t get the humidity right etc. but more often, it’s assuming that students don’t want to push too hard.
It totally dismisses bikram’s torture chamber analogy. as an instructor, i know that without real challenge, students get bored and move on to the next thing.
So to the east coast studios and anywhere else, turn up the heat!
August 8th, 2008 at 7:53 pm
I have to agree with ms day about the coddling. I just don’t get it. I practiced at bikram in the city in chicago and the room was nice and hot, until the instructor opened the door to let in cool air. This AFTER emphasizing the “suffering” etc.
Bikram Yoga students want it to be hard. Even those laying on their backs would rather take a break than breeze through class. Just ask them.
January 6th, 2009 at 10:05 pm
I don’t know, I just started Bikram and love it but I get really, really sick (like I am unable to drive, throwing up.) when I do 90, so if I scale back to 75 I am golden and I still get that beautiful feeling for a few days. I have a friend that had to go to the emergency room from Bikram. Severe dehydration. I wonder if people that have endocrine issues (like myself) bodies can’t cope?
January 7th, 2009 at 3:19 pm
Heather,
What do you mean “when you do 90 versus 70″? Do you mean 75% effort? If so, that is good. As a beginner you should pace yourself. Also, hydration is very important. Are you hydrated before class? I can’t speak to the medical issue you mention, but you should consult your doctor.
Here’s a question for you? If it was easy would you go back?